The Abridged version:
- After the city of Sacramento extended parking hours, Sacramento businesses and visitors have been frustrated by the change.
- City officials say the hours were extended to standardize meters across the city and keep a steady flow of foot traffic through Downtown and Midtown.
- Experts say that parking policy should be about “maintaining the curb,” or ensuring high turnover of people and parking.
Desiree Garnica, an Arden Arcade resident, met with her best friend for a day of brunch and shopping in Midtown Sacramento. When they went to extend their parking meter, the cost had reached $10 after three hours.
Both squinted at the signs to check the evening parking hours and saw they would have to feed the meter. They found themselves debating whether staying for dinner was worth the cost.
“I’ve been seeing that as a little bit of a bummer,” Garnica said. “Now, I’m trying to do plans kind of outside of Midtown.”
Garnica said the price, and the difficulty to find a spot, has been a deterrent when she considers returning to Midtown for evening plans. Especially when unsure how long she’ll be staying out, she’s been returning to Midtown less often.
And she’s not the only one. Following a change in July to extend the time parking meters operate until, increasing from a 6 p.m. stop time to 10 p.m., business owners and visitors are feeling the weight of the extended hours.
Increased parking rates were floated earlier this year to close a $66.2 million budget deficit, but the Sacramento City Council denied the proposal in August. They opted for extending hours and upping parking fines.
Sign Up for the Morning Newsletter
The Abridged morning newsletter lands in your inbox every weekday morning with the latest news from the Sacramento region.
Sacramento Mayor Kevin McCarty addressed the complaints about higher parking costs this year in his State of the City address. He said the changes were a key factor in closing that budget gap.
“We were looking at laying off police officers and firefighters, or making revenue increases such as parking,” he said in early November.
The decision was made to standardize all 2,800 meters in the city center, city parking manager Staci Kranitz said. Initially, 80% of those meters, most in Downtown, were already metered until 10 p.m. The remaining 20% were meters primarily in Midtown, she said.
Extending parking meter hours to 10 p.m. citywide is projected to generate about $580,000 in gross revenue, according to the city. Additional parking revenue streams like higher parking violation fines and 200 new metered spaces could bring in more than $4.6 million.
As for where parking revenue goes, Kranitz said that all meter and ticket revenue goes to the general fund. Meanwhile, revenue from the five city-owned parking garages is circulated to a fund responsible for covering the city’s parking operations.
Feeling Midtown’s parking woes
While city officials view the extended hours as a means to improve traffic flow and the city’s financial health, Midtown businesses argue the policy is driving away customers.
Jill Osur, owner of Teneral Cellars, noticed fewer customers after the changes, which led to the creation of the Lavender Alliance. Osur said one of the main priorities of the coalition is to establish accessible parking for customers in the Lavender Heights district.
“Everybody’s (sales are) down on our streets since they put the parking meters in,” Osur said. “That’s going to impact sales tax revenue and it doesn’t support the local businesses.”
In particular, Osur said she and 20 businesses are asking to switch the hours back to 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. enforcement. They’re also looking to add free holiday and Sunday parking.
“We want to encourage people to come down, to spend money, to really revitalize this neighborhood that is such an important part of the fabric of Sacramento,” she said.
City fields complaints
City officials recognize the frustration. However, they say the policy is meant to making parking easier. Councilmember Phil Pluckebaum said rising living costs can make the added fees sting more.
“When the parking ticket price goes up, I mean it stinks all the more because you know, folks just don’t have a lot of discretionary income or ability to pay those increased fees and tickets,” he said.
At the same time, Emily Baime Michaels, CEO of the Midtown Association, said that Lavender Heights has the most traffic in town. She’s sympathetic to maintaining the city’s budget but also recognizes the difficulties businesses are experiencing in the area.
“So we’re actually seeing that more people are coming in and parking despite additional regulations,” she said. “But that doesn’t mean that the businesses are necessarily feeling the additional benefit to their business.”
Finian Small-Scott, who works at Time Tested Books, said parking has always factored in to how businesses operate in Midtown. In some cases, to avoid parking, customers have been calling the store to have books mailed to them rather than picking them up, Small-Scott said.
“We just kind of take the hit on foot traffic because of the parking thing,” he said.
West Sacramento residents Eden Perkins and Aliyah Jennings will meet in Midtown for a bible study every week. Recently, they parked a few blocks from each other. Both said that they had to circle around a few times to find a parking space before meeting.
“I definitely try to come either early in the morning or late at night, just because I feel like late mornings and afternoons are the busiest,” Jennings said. “We’ll have to pay for parking, which definitely adds up over time.”
The right price for the curb
Michael Manville, a professor of urban planning at UCLA, explained that pricing street parking is a tool to manage traffic flow, not a city piggy bank.
“If you’re just raising rates because the city wants revenue, that’s a very different situation,” Manville said. “It means that you might be raising prices in places where spaces are currently underused … and if you raise a price in that situation, you’re going to reduce use and make the overall use of the system a little bit less efficient.”
The sweet spot, he said, is when one or two spaces are open on a given block. That indicates that spots are turning over, allowing more visitors to pull in without circling far from their intended destination.
While cities are looking at the extended meters as a tool for traffic turnover and helping with finances, the “human cost” is more top of mind for Tyler Glimstad, of Beers Books.
He’s seen his coworkers, primarily part-time workers and students, get hit with three or five tickets at once. He notes that enforcement and parking policy can feel “esoteric,” and for visitors who rely on driving in, it makes them reconsider making the trip again.
“If you’re doing a day out, you want it to be accessible,” Glimstad said. “If you have to worry about getting a ticket just for coming down to support local businesses, you just go somewhere else.”


