The Abridged version:
- The Sacramento City Council was expected to vote on whether to ban horse-drawn carriages for the Fab 40s holiday lights. The agenda item was pulled late Monday.
- Diana Newborn at Top Hand Ranch Carriage Company said a ban would have devastated her business, as the tradition makes up nearly 50% of her income.
- Residents like Richard Saxton said safety concerns are real. For him, the lack of lighting and large crowds worry him.
Editor’s note: This story was updated on Monday at 6:30 p.m. to reflect a change in the City Council agenda.
The Sacramento City Council was expected to vote Tuesday on a ban on horse-drawn carriages during the holiday season in East Sacramento’s Fab 40s.
The agenda item was pulled late Monday, Councilmember Phil Pluckebaum confirmed.
Pluckebaum told Abridged by PBS KVIE he has worked to balance the popularity of the horse-drawn carriages with the “real and legitimate concerns about safety and traffic and impacts” of the holiday light displays that draw thousands of visitors to the neighborhood.
“We pulled the item (from the council agenda) with the goal of doing a traffic management plan to see if we can mitigate the impacts on traffic and run the horses in a way that everyone thinks is safe,” he said.
Pluckebaum said there was an outpouring of support for the carriages on social media and that “there are definitely a lot of people who want to keep the horses.”
The city is attempting to enlist volunteers to help with traffic control, Pluckebaum said. A fundraising effort could also help hire staff to direct traffic.
The horse-drawn carriages have provided tours of the neighborhood for years.
Diana Newborn and her team at Top Hand Ranch Carriage Company have been preparing for the Fab 40s holiday lights since April. For Newborn, since 1970 she’s been navigating city permits, checking her horses’ health and teaching drivers how to be safe on the streets.
This year’s process was especially tricky, asking her to renew all her vehicles and have the horses certified with a veterinarian. For the last six months, all she heard from the city of Sacramento was that everything needs to be permitted.
Newborn was notified via email Friday of an emergency vote to potentially ban horse-drawn carriages for the Fab 40s.
“If we knew that this was going to happen, why am I testing my Fab 40 drivers?” Newborn said in an interview with Abridged by PBS KVIE before the agenda item was pulled. “If I thought this was going to happen, I would have been booking other jobs.”
Sign Up for the Morning Newsletter
The Abridged morning newsletter lands in your inbox every weekday morning with the latest news from the Sacramento region.
Horse-drawn vehicle tours have been a decades-long tradition at the Fab 40s holiday light displays. Schools and local organizations turn to horse carriage tours to fundraise and give back to the community. Anyone interested in a tour must book a year ahead, usually when Newborn opens the booking to the public on Jan. 1.
The event is more than 50% of her annual income. A ban, even just during this event, would put her out of business, she said, as she relies on that money to feed her 16 horses and pay insurance.
“This will be a reality check if this goes through,” she said. “This could devastate me to the point of putting me out of business.”
Newborn has seen other horse-drawn carriage businesses go out of business. When starting out, she said there were five competitors. Now, it’s just them.
The Sacramento City Council was expected to decide whether to ban horse-drawn carriages on Tuesday night. It would have taken effect immediately, if passed, in the “East Sacramento Holiday Zone” from Nov. 21 to Jan. 2.
“The city council finds that the unique and recurring seasonal conditions present an immediate threat to public safety and that prompt implementation of operational restrictions is necessary to reduce the risk of injury to pedestrians, passengers, motorists, and operators,” according to the report.
City documents state that the proposal was for safety concerns, citing reports and near misses. Tens of thousands of people combined with potential external stimuli could lead to unpredictable reactions from the horses, according to the staff report.
In particular, the report points to a December 2025 incident when a firework noise spooked a horse, which “jumped a curb before stopping in a resident’s yard.”
Richard Saxton, a resident of East Sacramento for more than 25 years, said the horse-drawn carriages, at night especially, are a concern to him.
He lives on the outskirts of the Fab 40s and said his nearby street experiences the traffic but has fewer lights.
“It has gotten more congested over time, but that’s because people have gotten more and more into decorating, so more people come to see it,” he said before the vote was taken off the council agenda. “I think that’s all good. But the horse-drawn carriages and hay wagons make me a little nervous.”
Newborn also said responsibility falls on local enforcement. Last year, she said the city installed new signs for the carriages’ routes. But they had already been following those guidelines.
“We’ve been doing that for over 20 some-odd years,” she said. “Going with the flow.”


