The Abridged version:
- Keyla Vasconellos recommends these 15 bakeries, farms and restaurants from Lodi to Apple Hill taking Thanksgiving pie orders this year.
- Some deadlines fall on Friday, Nov. 20, and most pickups land on Nov. 24 or 25.
- Classic pumpkin and apple share the list with a purple sweet potato tart, a Meyer lemon tart and a pie packed with three kinds of nuts.
Pie is usually the one Thanksgiving dish people make room for, no matter how full they are after a second plate of stuffing.
Luckily, the Sacramento region has no shortage of bakers who take it seriously. I tasted my way through every pie on this list, and each one earned its spot.
With orchards and farms in nearly every direction, the options range from a Lodi winery baking a mother’s decades-old recipes to an Apple Hill farm known for a pie invented to be eaten with your hands. There’s also a Midtown gelato shop making its very first holiday pumpkin pie with candied pepitas and pumpkin jam, and a Downtown Sacramento institution whose banana cream pie has been feeding lawmakers since the 1940s.
Whether you’re hosting a crowd or have been tasked with bringing dessert, these picks will put you in charge of pie every year. Here’s where to order them around Sacramento before the rush.
Frank Fat’s
806 L St., Sacramento

Frank Fat’s has been feeding the Capitol crowd in Downtown Sacramento since 1939, and its banana cream pie has been closing out those meals since the 1940s. Today’s pie still follows the recipe Frank Fat created with his original chef nearly 80 years ago.
Fresh-sliced bananas are folded into rich custard in a flaky, buttery crust, then topped with a cloud of whipped cream. Chocolate lovers can look forward to a chocolate cream pie too, and both are available whole for Thanksgiving with a call ahead and pickup on Wednesday, Nov. 25.
Real Pie Company
2425 24th St., Suite A, Sacramento

At Real Pie Company off Broadway, owners Kira O’Donnell Babich and Fred Babich build their pies around whatever is in season at small farms in the region. The November menu runs from a traditional pumpkin and a pecan pie baked with maple syrup and brown butter to a Pink Lady and Granny Smith apple galette and a lattice-topped Montmorency cherry pie.
For something bright, there’s the Lemon Lust pie, which the shop describes as lemony and sassy. Thanksgiving orders come with a four-item limit and a single pickup day, Wednesday, Nov. 25.
I Love Pie Bakeshop
6241 Fair Oaks Blvd., Carmichael

Rows of whipped cream piped into little hearts may make the banana cream at I Love Pie Bakeshop the cutest pie in Sacramento County. Owner Diana Shockley balances bright meringue pies like lemon raspberry and cranberry lemon with richer picks like bourbon pecan and salted caramel Dutch apple. Pies come in a six-inch size that serves two to three and an eight-inch that serves five to six, and Thanksgiving preorders are open online.
Pistachio & Cream
1801 L St., Suite 60, Sacramento

Pistachio & Cream opened on L Street in Midtown in June, which makes it the newest spot on this list. The Italian-style gelato shop is baking the fanciest pumpkin pie in town, finished with white chocolate vanilla bean Chantilly, candied pepitas and housemade pumpkin jam.
A seven-inch pie cuts into six slices for $17.95, and a nine-inch yields 10 slices for $19.95, some of the lowest prices on this list. Order with two days’ notice, and keep it in mind for a last-minute save, since the shop plans to open on Thanksgiving Day.
Crumb Bakeshop
680 Fifth St., Lincoln

Crumb Bakeshop got its start when Mary Jaques sold her prizewinning apple crumb pie to pay for her son’s class trip to New York. That fundraiser grew into a dessert truck at farmers markets around the region and, eventually, a shop in Downtown Lincoln.
The apple crumb that started it all is on the Thanksgiving menu, alongside a salted caramel pear and a pumpkin pie with a graham cracker crust. Orders go through the website only, with pickup on Wednesday, Nov. 25.
Ikeda’s
13500 Lincoln Way, Auburn and 26295 Mace Blvd., Davis

USA Today readers voted Ikeda’s the No. 1 pie shop in the country this year. Long before that, road-trippers on their way to Lake Tahoe knew the family-run Auburn stop off Interstate 80 for its burgers, fruit pie milkshakes and a country market stocked with orchard fruit, local wine and snacks for the drive.
For Thanksgiving, seasonal pumpkin and pecan join a lineup of fruit pies like razzleberry, strawberry rhubarb and marionberry. Ikeda’s stops taking online orders the week of the holiday, so every pie that week goes first come, first served.
Majka Pizzeria & Bakery
1704 15th St., Sacramento

Majka built its following on sourdough pizza, and for Thanksgiving the bakery side is turning out a Meyer lemon tart and a pumpkin pie. Owners Alex Sherry and Chutharat Sae Tong came to Sacramento from Berkeley’s Cheeseboard Collective, and that background shows in their cheese boxes, packed with hard-to-find cheeses you won’t see at most shops, an easy add-on to round out the holiday spread. Order online or by phone for pickup through Wednesday, Nov. 25, and don’t wait, since Sherry expects both to sell out.
Ettore’s Bakery & Café
2376 Fair Oaks Blvd., Sacramento

Hosts who would rather not cook at all can hand the whole Thanksgiving dinner over to Ettore’s in Arden Arcade, which takes preorders for complete holiday meals. Its fall pies come in pumpkin, pecan, cranberry walnut and apple, and they’re available to take home all month for anyone who can’t wait until the big day. Dinners must be preordered and picked up between 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. on Wednesday, Nov. 25.
Estelle Bakery & Pâtisserie
615 David J. Stern Walk, Suite 100, Sacramento; 2530 Arden Way, Sacramento; 2710 Fifth St., Davis

Stepping into any of Estelle’s shops in Downtown Sacramento, Arden Arcade and Davis feels like ducking into a little Parisian pâtisserie. Find rows of pastel macarons glowing under the glass beside glossy lemon tarts and cream puff cakes crowned in caramelized sugar.
Holiday orders close at noon on Friday, Nov. 20, and you can place yours by phone or email. This year’s four large desserts include a pumpkin pie, a sea salt caramel chocolate tart and a pecan pie topped with vanilla Chantilly. The caramel apple pie comes layered over almond cream and finished with a salty caramel drizzle.
Putah Creek Cafe
1 Main St., Winters

Putah Creek Cafe has been a Main Street fixture in Winters for more than 35 years, and its holiday dessert menu is worth the drive west. The standout is the Tri-Nut pie packed with almonds, walnuts and pecans, which the cafe sums up as a pecan pie, only better. A Dutch apple pie with a cinnamon-sugar crumble and a classic pumpkin round out the lineup. Preorder online for pickup Tuesday, Nov. 24, or Wednesday, Nov. 25.
Faria Bakery
3417 Broadway, Sacramento

Faria takes Thanksgiving dessert somewhere unexpected, with a chocolate pecan rye tart and a purple sweet potato tart alongside a salted caramel apple pie. The bakery also makes milk bread dinner rolls by the six-pack, an easy way to upgrade the breadbasket while you’re at it. When preordering online, pick a Nov. 24 or 25 pickup date at the North Oak Park shop first, or the holiday items will show as unavailable. They go fast, so order sooner rather than later.
Michael David Winery
4580 W. Highway 12, Lodi

The pies at Michael David Winery in Lodi come from recipes collected and refined by the mother of brothers Michael and David Phillips, and the family says they haven’t changed in decades. Each one is baked to order in the winery’s own bakery, which shares the property with the tasting room pouring the family’s bold zinfandels. This year’s Thanksgiving lineup includes apple, apple-cranberry, pumpkin and pumpkin-walnut, all $25 apiece. Reserve a pie on Tock for pickup at the winery on Nov. 24 or 25.
Tower Cafe
1518 Broadway, Sacramento

Tower Cafe has been a Land Park brunch institution for decades, tucked beside the historic Tower Theatre with a palm-shaded patio and a dining room filled with art from around the world. For the holidays, the cafe sells its pies whole, and the lineup sticks to the classics. Banana cream and apple crumble share the menu with a chocolate cream pie piled with whipped cream and shards of dark chocolate over a chocolate cookie crust.
Order by phone or online and plan to pick up before the holiday, since the restaurant closes on Thanksgiving Day. If you’re headed to the in-laws’ for breakfast that weekend, Tower’s famous French toast comes in a take-and-bake version that needs just 12 to 15 minutes in the oven, an easy way to rack up brownie points with the family.
Freeport Bakery
2966 Freeport Blvd., Sacramento

Generations of Land Park families have picked up their birthday cakes and holiday desserts at Freeport Bakery. This is its first Thanksgiving since Ettore’s owner Lisa Calk took over from longtime owners Marlene and Walter Goetzeler, who retired in September. The menu runs from spiced pumpkin and pecan to Dutch apple and peach berry, plus a pumpkin cheesecake for the guest who always passes on pie. Preorders close at 3 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 20, and walk-ins can shop the case Nov. 24 and 25.
Joan’s Apple Bakery at Delfino Farms
3205 N. Canyon Road, Camino

For apple pie, Joan’s Apple Bakery at Delfino Farms in Apple Hill is the place, and the smell of fresh pies coming out of the oven hits the moment you walk in. Joan “Nanny” Delfino invented the Walkin’ Pie so her seven kids could eat apple pie outside like a hamburger, and the bakery still serves it with cider sauce and vanilla ice cream.
For the holiday table, choose from the five-pound Farmhouse Pie, the three-pound Cottage Pie or a crumb-topped French apple that Joan named for her French roots. Preorders go through the farm’s website and need to be placed and paid a week ahead. Make a day of it by heading across the parking lot to Edio Vineyards, where a pie run can turn into an afternoon of wine tasting.
Correction: This story was updated at 1:25 p.m. Friday, Nov. 13, to remove an inaccurate reference to a retailer.



