The Abridged version:
- Due to large community support for the event, the Sacramento City Council pulled a vote to ban horse-drawn carriages for the Fab 40s holiday lights.
- Dianna Newborn at Top Hand Ranch Carriage Company said that even though the vote will not happen Tuesday night, she’s still nervous for the future.
- Councilmember Phil Pluckebaum said that the issue boils down to traffic and congestion in the area.
An outpouring of community support saved a beloved Sacramento holiday tradition. Soon, horse-drawn carriages will roll through the Fab 40s just as they have for years.
After a rush toward an emergency vote to ban the rides through East Sacramento this holiday season, the City Council pulled the proposal late Monday night. Officials had cited safety and traffic concerns.
The move to stop the vote didn’t wipe away Dianna Newborn’s fear for her business — and officials are weighing crowd-control solutions.
“I’m happy that I can work this year,” Newborn, the owner of Top Hand Ranch Carriage Company, said. “But what about years to come?”
Why was a ban being considered?
While the city report said that the ban would address unique safety concerns, Councilmember Phil Pluckebaum said that the issue really boils down to traffic and congestion.
“We’ve created a traffic nuisance is the legal term,” he said Tuesday. “There’s a bunch of people that want to enjoy this festive environment that the neighborhood has created and every year it seems like the traffic has gotten worse.”
Pluckebaum said volunteers or event management, similar to a festival or parade, could help address traffic flow. However, with no central funding or organization to plan it, finding services would be a challenge.
From his perspective, the horse-drawn carriages are bringing in “multiple overlapping levels of concerns.” He’s hearing safety, traffic and general noise concerns from neighbors and even talking with people in New York on their horse-carriage ban.
Moving forward, Pluckebaum said he doesn’t expect the conversation to resurface if the traffic issue is addressed well this year.
“I don’t expect it’ll ever come back on the table,” he said. “But if there is strong support from the public at some point in the future to reopen this discussion, that’s certainly possible.”
Dimitry Saras, president of the East Sacramento Community Association, said that most of the complaints he hears from residents are about traffic during this time of year. Most notably, people can’t leave their homes from 4 to 10 p.m. during the holiday season, starting in late November.
However, he doesn’t see how four or five horse carriages can have that large of an impact on the traffic.
“We totally understand that a lot of people enjoy them,” Saras said. “Because if people don’t enjoy them, then you wouldn’t see them there, right? We just had a lot of neighbors come and talk about ‘hey, the traffic’s getting really bad.’”
A seat at the table
Newborn’s main frustration is that she hasn’t heard much from the city about whether her company will have reliable business.
“I can’t get any information from anybody,” Newborn said. “That’s the whole thing. I’ve left a message for the city of Sacramento to call me. No phone calls back. I’m left in the dark.”
For Newborn, even though her horses are in business this year, she still wants to be at the table for future events.
“I would think I would be at the table when it comes to my business,” she said. “I will be at the City Council tonight.”
Correction: A previous version of this story misspelled Dianna Newborn’s first name.




